Alexander Schmorell’s visit in Ulm

Question: Who was present during the discussions in the residence of Scholl’s parents in Ulm?

Answer: With regards to the time in question, I must say in advance that this was not over Christmas, but rather November 1942 [Note 1],because I did not travel to Ulm over Christmas or New Year’s.

Additionally, we never included the parents of the Scholl siblings in our discussions. We strictly avoided telling the Scholl parents or Inge Scholl anything about our plans.

I can recall that once a high school student from Ulm named Hans Hirzel took part in our discussions. As best as I can recall, we told Hirzel about our plan only in broad strokes, namely how we wished to usher in another form of government, and asked for his cooperation. In any event, Hirzel did not assume a negative attitude. But I cannot remember his exact words at this moment. Hirzel left after this discussion. I have not seen him since, nor have I had any contact with him.

Question: Who was additionally involved in these discussions in Ulm? It has been stated that a member of the Air Force, about 170 – 172 cm tall [5’ 6” – 5’7”], slender, dark brown hair, long reddish face, was also present in Scholl’s apartment at that time. [Note 2]

Answer: I cannot recall that during my stay in this residence any member of the Air Force would have come by and participated in our discussion. I do recall that once when Hans Scholl and I had gone out, someone supposedly came by and asked for him. I cannot state whether this was that particular member of the military or a civilian, because I never learned anything more about it.

I remember the high school student named Hirzel well. If a member of the military had been present during our discussion with him, I would certainly be able to recall that man. But since I have no memory of such a thing, I believe I can state with certainty that we (Hans and Sophia Scholl, Hirzel, and I) never devised our revolutionary plans in the presence of this member of the military. I cannot recall that such a man ever interrupted [our discussions]. Therefore I cannot possibly give any leads regarding his name. If I were able to do so, I would say so freely and clearly.

Since in the interim Hans Scholl never mentioned the military man in question, it can likely be well established that he had no knowledge of our plan and that a co-conspiracy must be out of the question, since otherwise I would have known about it.

I cannot name any additional persons, who could have had knowledge of my crime. I have told the whole truth and am no longer in the position to name any additional friends.


Note 1: Schmauß must have spoken but not written the part about Christmas, because it does not appear in the question recorded in the transcript.

Note 2: In Hans Hirzel’s interrogation, he had stated that this member of the Air Force was present during their discussions over Christmas. Perhaps Schmauß was trying to trip Alexander Schmorell up.


Source: March 13, 1943 interrogation of Alexander Schmorell


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s